nwslttr
⏩ Forwarded this email? Subscribe to get your own copy here
Attribution and the Cost of Misunderstood Marketing
By Jessika Ödling
For more than a decade, attribution has served as digital marketing’s north star. It told us where to spend, what was working, and who deserved the credit. Clicks became conversions. Conversions became KPIs. And for a while, that was enough.
But somewhere along the way, something shifted. Campaigns started performing better on paper than they did in terms of actual business outcomes. Performance marketers have been underserved, forced to use systems that measure what's easy, instead of what actually matters.
Attribution has long been the default for measuring marketing impact. But most models still rely almost entirely on clicks, ignoring view-throughs, post-purchase behavior, or upper-funnel influence. That means brands end up optimizing for the small percentage of users who actually click, while overlooking the broader drivers of demand. As tracking restrictions tighten and session data becomes increasingly unreliable, it’s getting harder to trust what those models are really telling us.
Most attribution frameworks today offer an oversimplified, often skewed version of the story based on incomplete signals. In a reality where budgets are under pressure and every channel, now more than ever, has the incentive to prove results, that’s no longer enough. To understand what actually drives value, brands need more than an oversimplification of interactions. They need a way to isolate effect. That’s where incrementality comes in.
The Limits of Attribution Logic
Attribution systems are designed to track interactions and assign credit. That makes sense in theory, and for a long time, it worked well enough. But as customer journeys became more fragmented, and as platforms began to report their own versions of the truth, the cracks started to show.
If a customer saw three ads, opened an email, visited your site twice, and finally purchased through a branded search, which touchpoint(s) should get credit for it? Ask your attribution model, and it will answer. Ask your finance team, and they’ll likely raise an eyebrow.
What Incrementality Testing Actually Does
Incrementality testing offers something attribution can’t: a causal framework. Rather than tracking paths and assigning credit, incrementality isolates the true lift of a marketing activity. It does this by comparing a group of users exposed to a campaign with a statistically similar group that wasn’t. The difference in outcomes, whether that be conversions, revenue, or the number of new customers, is the incremental effect.
Would you like to be a guest blogger on eCommerce Tech? Apply here
Popular on the Blog:
Explore the whole blog here
How Jennifer Aniston’s LolaVie brand grew sales 40% with CTV ads
For its first CTV campaign, Jennifer Aniston’s DTC haircare brand LolaVie had a few non-negotiables. The campaign had to be simple. It had to demonstrate measurable impact. And it had to be full-funnel.
LolaVie used Roku Ads Manager to test and optimize creatives — reaching millions of potential customers at all stages of their purchase journeys. Roku Ads Manager helped the brand convey LolaVie’s playful voice while helping drive omnichannel sales across both ecommerce and retail touchpoints.
The campaign included an Action Ad overlay that let viewers shop directly from their TVs by clicking OK on their Roku remote. This guided them to the website to buy LolaVie products.
Discover how Roku Ads Manager helped LolaVie drive big sales and customer growth with self-serve TV ads.
The DTC beauty category is crowded. To break through, Jennifer Aniston’s brand LolaVie, worked with Roku Ads Manager to easily set up, test, and optimize CTV ad creatives. The campaign helped drive a big lift in sales and customer growth, helping LolaVie break through in the crowded beauty category.
Tech to Explore
Looking for new solutions to your growth problems?
Our Featured Partners
RevLifter - An AI-powered platform that personalizes eCommerce deals and offers in real-time to boost conversions and average order value. Try us free for 90 days
Decile - AI-powered eCommerce analytics platform that empowers eCommerce teams to move faster and more strategically. Scale insights, improve marketing outcomes, and uncover areas of opportunity instantly. Schedule a Demo
Klaviyo - Powerful email marketing solution designed for eCommerce businesses. Sign Up Now
Events for your Diary
We're busy getting our event directory fully up to date for 2026... if you have an event we should be promoting, submit it here
Want to get the most out of ChatGPT?
ChatGPT is a superpower if you know how to use it correctly.
Discover how HubSpot's guide to AI can elevate both your productivity and creativity to get more things done.
Learn to automate tasks, enhance decision-making, and foster innovation with the power of AI.
Advert.
Want to advertise to our audience? We’d love to hear from you



